Magazine Cover
Press to zoom

Buy a PDF

ARCHIVE FOR 2016    RUSSIAN

Сентябрь 2016

CONTENT

 

 

Alexey Artyukh How Tax Authorities Could Challenge Price of a Transaction: Discretion Increases
Case comment on the judgment of RF SC No.305-КГ16-4920, 22 July 2016
Buy a PDF

 

Alexander Latyev Universal Succession vs Community Property: Registration Wins
Case comment on the judgment of RF SC No. 308-КГ15-19017, 17 June 2016
Buy a PDF

 

 

Daniil Tuzov A State Procurement Contract Failed. What Happens to the Fee Paid for Its Conclusion?
Case comment on the judgment of RF SC No. 306-ЭС16-606,14 June 2016
Buy a PDF

 

Igor Yastrzhembskiy Construction: Permit Impossible to Prohibit
Case comment on the judgment of RF SC No. 305-ЭС16-2309, 12 July 2016
Buy a PDF

 

 

FREE TRIBUNE

Yuliy Tay Per aspera ad astra, or Court Reform, Two Years, All Systems Performing Well?
The article analyses the functioning of the Chamber for Commercial Disputes of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation (SC RF) and compares it with the Supreme Arbitrazh Court of the Russian Federation (SAC RF). The comparison is based on the two-year practice of the new Chamber. The article also gives an overall assessment of the clarifications issued by the SC RF after it replaced the SAC RF. The author notes the shortcomings of the reform of the highest instance for economic disputes and proposes solutions to improve procedure in the Chamber for Commercial Disputes.
Keywords: cassation, the Supreme Court, arbitrazh (commercial) procedure, supervision (extraordinary appeal), judge
Buy a PDF

 

Andrey Egorov Charge by Court Order: Theoretical and Practical Problems. In Russia and Abroad
Regulation that treats court injunctions as charging orders has recently been enacted in Russia. The article argues that this type of charges (by court orders) should be developed with the use of foreign experience. It also criticises the trend emerging in court practice that treats this instrument with suspicion and tries to limit it as far as possible. The article proves that the charge is created by both injunction that supports execution of a judgment (execution injunction) and interim injunction. The last type of charge should be transformed into a charge by execution injunction when and if the court upholds the claim. This transformation allows keeping charge priority that is determined by the date of the injunction order. The article also argues that the charge by court order should remain in force even when the chargor goes into bankruptcy. However, it could be challenged as providing unfair preference to the chargee based on the same principles that legislation provides for challenging contractual charge. Another type of charge considered by the article is the charge of money on a bank account. The article concludes that court order could create this type of charge irrespective of whether the money is kept on a special charge account. Moreover, the charge could cover not only actual money on the account but also money that will be transferred to it in the future. In both cases the priority of claims relating to the same account should be determined by the date when the writ of enforcement was delivered into the bank.
Keywords: charge, charge by court order, bank account charge, security, bankruptcy
Buy a PDF

 

Dmitry Stepanov Economic Analysis of Corporate Law
This article provides an overview of key concepts of economic analysis of corporate law. The cornerstone thesis of corporate law and economics goes back to neoclassical economic idea that regardless initial property rights distribution contracting parties may achieve effective agreement if transactional costs are neglect, thus the firm is a legal device which helps to reduce the cost of contracting. Therefore, contractarian theory of the firm has become predominant concept in legal theory and shaped the debate on who are the ultimate beneficiaries of the governance of the firm and how to define optimal default rules they need. The paper also analyzes an agency problem, then conflicts between various corporate constituencies, mostly shareholders and creditors, as well as it outlines efficient market hypothesis and how this concept was incorporated into economic analysis of corporations. The article concludes by economics of mergers activity and regulatory competition between various corporate jurisdictions with a number of normative implications that economic analysis may provide for legal policy.
Keywords: economic analysis of law, law and economics, contractarian theory, social cost, agency problem, efficient capital market hypothesis, regulatory competition

 

Vladislav Kostko Retention of an Object which is not in Debtor’s Ownership
This article examines how the party who has exercised his right to retention (retentor) could protect himself against claims by both the debtor and any other person. The analysis is based on the understanding of the nature of the retention as described in the article. It is argued that retention is neither a right (in rem or in personam) nor a transaction. The only thing that the retentor could do is to object the claim for recovery of the retained thing. Principally, this is the way in which an illegal possessor could protect his possession. Moreover, the retentor’s right to sell the retained property is the consequence not of the retention but of other facts and circumstances. The theory of retention developed in this article suggests that the retentor has protection only against those persons who are obliged to cover expenses associated with the retained property or pay other debts to the retentor. In general, if the retained property does not belong to the debtor, this means that retentor is entitled to hold it, but is unable to sell. The defense against the thing’s proprietor is possible only in certain cases: when he can be charged with the expenses incurred in connection with this thing or when he acts in defense of the debtor.
Keywords: retention, transaction, illegal possessor, vindication, pledge
Buy a PDF